Before you say anything

Preparing for a Police Investigation and Interrogation in Israel

A phone call summoning you to a police interview can come to anyone, and it is natural to fear the worst.

What you say in the first interview may decide the fate of the file. Legal advice before you enter the interview room protects your rights and prevents mistakes that cannot be undone.

A phone call summoning you to a police interview can come to anyone, including people who have never had any dealings with the law. This is the moment for advice before the interview: to understand where you stand, what to answer, what rights you have and how to arrive calm and prepared, so that the risk of an indictment is reduced.

Advice before the interview

A police interview is stressful, especially for someone seeing the inside of an interview room for the first time. In my experience, walking in unprepared often leads to serious mistakes that could have been avoided. It is not an innocent conversation. You are at a real disadvantage, every word you say is recorded, and investigators are allowed to use interrogation techniques that you may not even notice.

I am here to prevent that. Before you speak, you take advice, settle a strategy, learn your rights and arrive prepared. If you have been summoned, you do not have to face it alone: contact our firm and we will get back to you quickly.

How a police investigation proceeds

The summons and the interview

The summons comes by telephone or by formal letter, sometimes stating the suspicion. Preparation starts here, by establishing whether you are called as a witness or as a suspect, which is a fundamental difference, and by arranging advice. At the station the investigator asks questions, sometimes presenting documents or recordings. If you are suspected of an offence, the interview is conducted under caution, and you will be warned of your status and your rights, such as the right to consult a lawyer, the right not to incriminate yourself and the right to remain silent.

Detention or arrest

Detention or arrest may follow where there is a concern that the investigation will be obstructed, that the suspect poses a danger or that the suspect will flee. Contact a criminal lawyer at once to examine alternatives and release.

The prosecution’s decision

When the investigation ends, the file passes to the police prosecution or the State Attorney’s Office, which may decide on one of the following:

  • Closing the file for lack of guilt (a finding that you did not commit the offence), for insufficient evidence, or because the circumstances do not justify prosecution, commonly called “lack of public interest”. Only closure for lack of guilt leaves a clean police record, so whenever a file is closed on another ground, an application to change the ground of closure should be made through a skilled criminal lawyer.
  • A conditional arrangement as an alternative to an indictment, where certain conditions are met and at the prosecution’s discretion. Its terms are negotiated with the prosecution, the penalty may be a fine, community service, referral to treatment through a probation officer or compensation to the victim, and once you meet the conditions the file is closed.
  • Further investigation before a decision. The file is still open and you may be summoned again, which makes this the time to strengthen your defence.
  • An indictment and a criminal trial, which may end in a plea agreement or in a full evidentiary hearing in which the prosecution tries to prove through witnesses that you committed the offence.

Where the indictment would be for a felony (an offence punishable by more than 3 years’ imprisonment), you have a right to a hearing under section 60A of the Criminal Procedure Law before it is filed, to try to persuade the prosecution not to indict. It is your last opportunity to change the course of the file, so representation at that hearing matters a great deal. We explain the process on our page on closing criminal files and pre-indictment hearings.

Your rights when questioned

  • The right to know your status. A witness sometimes becomes a suspect during the interview itself. Watch for this and act accordingly.
  • The right to consult a lawyer. You may stop at any stage and ask to consult a lawyer. This is the most important right you have, so use it as early as possible.
  • The right to remain silent and not to incriminate yourself. Silence may strengthen the suspicion against you, however, so consult a criminal lawyer before relying on it.
  • Language, health and medication. You have the right to be questioned in your own language, and the right to medical care and medication.
  • No violence, threats or humiliation. You may not be physically harmed, threatened or put under unreasonable pressure. If that happens, ask to stop the interview and contact a lawyer immediately.

Interrogation techniques: what is permitted and what is not

Within certain limits, investigators are allowed to use stratagems known as interrogation techniques. The best known is “good cop, bad cop”, but others are also permitted: reasonable pressure, changes of pace, raising the voice, confronting you with documents, correspondence or photographs, and sometimes misleading statements about the state of the evidence, partial information or a planted informant. Violence of any kind, prolonged humiliation, improper threats, denial of medical care or medication, impersonating a lawyer or another professional, fabricating evidence and breaching lawyer-client privilege are all prohibited.

When in doubt, stop, ask for your status to be clarified and ask to consult a lawyer before continuing. Do not volunteer information or guess at facts. The investigator does not decide the fate of your file, so do not be drawn by promises of a lighter sentence or a closed file.

When the person questioned is a minor

Children up to the age of 14 are questioned by a child investigator, who is a social worker and not a police officer. Young people up to 18 are questioned by a youth investigator, and in most cases a parent or responsible adult has the right to be present. Advice before the interview helps prevent the pressure that leads to false admissions.

Ten practical points for anyone summoned to a police interview

  • Establish your status. If you are a suspect, you must be warned that you do not have to say anything before consulting a lawyer. Insist on that warning, and use it.
  • Consult a criminal lawyer in advance, so that you know the suspicions against you and arrive with a strategy.
  • There are no innocent conversations at the station. In all likelihood you are recorded and filmed in corridors, holding cells and seating areas too. Do not discuss the case with anyone other than your lawyer.
  • Remain silent until you have legal advice, so as not to make incriminating statements.
  • Do not lie under any circumstances. It can entangle you later.
  • If you decide to speak, be brief and consistent, and keep to one version.
  • Do not sign what you do not fully understand. Ask a lawyer to explain if needed.
  • Know the common interrogation techniques, and do not be misled by promises.
  • Read the interview record carefully before signing it, more than once if possible, and ask for corrections first. Every word counts.
  • Do not give the code to your phone without advice, even if you are shown a search warrant. The Supreme Court has recently recognised the phone as a private device entitled to enhanced protection. I see people hand over the code because they feel they have nothing to hide, and that is a mistake: the information on a phone can entangle you, those close to you and others you were in contact with.

After the interview, and what a lawyer does for you

Once you have been questioned, everything is still open. The prosecution may close the file, order further investigation, hold a section 60A hearing for serious offences, offer a conditional arrangement or file an indictment. Before the interview, advice settles a consistent line (silence, a partial answer or a full one) and prepares you for interrogation techniques. After it, an experienced criminal lawyer establishes the status of the file, applies to change the ground of closure if the file was not closed for lack of guilt, negotiates with the prosecution and, where necessary, represents you at the hearing or at trial.

I have practised criminal law, extradition and international crime since 1998, and I serve as Chairman of the Extradition and International Crime Committee of the Israel Bar Association. Whether you have been summoned or are already waiting for the next stage, contact us for a discreet consultation. We can be reached 24/7 on +972-3-6969080.

Frequently asked questions

I was summoned to an interview by phone. Do I have to attend?

Usually, yes. Failing to attend may lead to enforcement steps, such as being brought in under a warrant. If the date is a problem, contact the investigator straight away to ask for a short postponement, and consult a criminal lawyer about how to respond and what to bring.

Will taking advice before the interview strengthen the suspicion against me?

No. Consulting a lawyer is a basic right designed to protect you: to understand your status, map the risks, decide how to answer (fully, partly or not at all) and avoid giving up rights without realising it. In our experience, professional preparation reduces mistakes and confusion, especially in a first interview.

I was questioned. Do I now have a criminal record?

An interview under caution creates a police record. This is not a court criminal record but an internal entry in police records, open to bodies specified by law. If the file is closed for lack of guilt, no record remains. If it is closed on another ground, an application to change the ground of closure can be considered.

The investigator asked for the code to my phone. Do I have to give it?

No. Do not give the code without consulting a lawyer, even if the investigator shows you a search warrant. Handing it over may harm your privacy and your rights, and expose extensive information about you and the people you were in contact with.

Should I remain silent in the interview?

It depends on the circumstances. Silence protects against self-incrimination, but it may carry evidential weight later. A lawyer reviews the material and your status and advises on silence, a partial answer or a full one. That decision is made before the questions begin, while there is still time to think.

Can a witness statement turn into an interview under caution?

Yes, and it is not especially rare. That is another reason to consult a criminal lawyer before going to the police station and to be ready for every scenario.

This page provides general information and is not a substitute for legal advice based on the facts of a particular case. A Hebrew version of this page is available at הכנה לחקירה במשטרה – מה עושים לפני שמדברים.