Before an indictment is filed

Closing a Criminal File and Pre-Indictment Hearings in Israel

How a file is closed, and the hearing under section 60A, decide whether a police record stays with you or is erased.

A file closed for insufficient evidence still leaves a police record, and a section 60A hearing may stop an indictment. We act at both points, within the time limits set by law.

If you have been questioned by the police in Israel, or a letter has told you that your file has gone to the prosecution, two moments now matter most. One is the way the file is closed, because the ground for closure decides whether a police record stays with you. The other is the hearing under section 60A of the Criminal Procedure Law, the chance to persuade the prosecution not to indict at all. With an experienced criminal defence lawyer it is possible to work towards closing the file, changing the ground for closure to “lack of guilt” and erasing the police record, so that your reputation and your work are protected.

The pending file and the police record

From the moment a person is questioned, a file is opened in their name. In Israel it is known as a “mabad” file, meaning a file awaiting a decision on whether an indictment will be filed. It comes with an internal entry in police records, known as a police record, even where the investigation never ended in an indictment.

The record is open to bodies specified by law, such as the Israel Police, the Military Police, the Israel Security Agency, the IDF Intelligence Directorate and the Mossad, and it shows the investigation file, the type of offences and the status of the investigation. It can lead to cancellation of a firearms licence, suspension or dismissal from a public post, or refusal of membership of bodies such as government ministries, the Israel Bar Association and the Auditors’ Council.

A police record must be distinguished from a criminal record, which follows a court proceeding and a conviction and has its own rules on expiry and erasure under the Criminal Register and Rehabilitation of Offenders Law. This page concerns the police record. After any police interview, the first thing to check is whether the file has been closed, and on which ground.

Closing the file, and why the ground matters

The fate of the file is decided when the material passes to the prosecuting authorities: the police, the State Attorney’s Office or the court, according to the division of powers set by law. The best decision is closure, but the law sets several grounds for closure, and only one of them leaves no police record:

  • Lack of guilt. A finding that the suspect did not commit the offence, even after all the evidence collected has been examined. The file is erased entirely from the police record and leaves no mark on the suspect’s work, licence or reputation.
  • Insufficient evidence. The police collected evidence but could not build a sufficient basis for an indictment. The ground implies doubt, because the suspect’s account did not clear them entirely. The file stays in the police record, which may reach enforcement authorities, public bodies and even prospective employers.
  • The circumstances do not justify prosecution, commonly called “lack of public interest”. There is enough evidence but no public interest in prosecuting, for example because the offence is relatively minor, many years have passed or the suspect’s personal circumstances weigh against it. This ground also leaves a police record.

Changing the ground of closure to lack of guilt

Whenever a file has not been closed for lack of guilt, an application to change the ground of closure should be considered. It is one of the main ways to erase a police record, and it is a legal proceeding in every sense:

  • Finding out the actual ground. In most cases the police do not state it in the notice of closure, so the record has to be inspected at the station.
  • Reviewing the investigation material. The lawyer copies the evidence and looks for gaps or mistakes in the investigation. Sometimes a single contradiction is enough.
  • Filing the application with the prosecutor who closed the file. It must be reasoned and rest on the law, personal circumstances or further evidence.
  • The decision and the appeal. If the application is accepted, the record is erased and the suspect’s name is cleared. If it is refused, an appeal may be filed within 60 days. The right of appeal can be used only once, so the appeal has to build a new and more persuasive argument.

Only in exceptional cases can a petition be brought to the High Court of Justice against the dismissal of the appeal. Otherwise, a substantial period set by law must pass, and certain conditions must be met, before applying to erase the record. Separately, the police record of a file closed for insufficient evidence or lack of public interest, for an offence that is not a felony, is cancelled automatically 7 years after the event, or 5 years in the case of a minor. Our long-standing familiarity with the State Attorney’s Office can help at this stage.

Other outcomes after the investigation

A conditional arrangement in place of an indictment

For less serious offences, a conditional arrangement ends the criminal proceeding without a conviction and without a court appearance. The suspect admits the facts and meets set conditions, such as a fine or compensation, community service or treatment, and the file is then closed. It does leave a police record, but it brings a quick end, certainty and a moderate penalty. Its terms are negotiated with the prosecution, so representation matters.

Further investigation

Sometimes the material is not enough for the prosecution to decide, and the file is returned to the police with instructions, for example to question further witnesses or collect missing evidence. The file is still open, and this is the time to strengthen the defence.

An indictment

If an indictment is filed, the suspect becomes a defendant. The case may end in a plea agreement with the prosecution, covering the offences admitted and sometimes the sentence, or in a full trial in which the prosecution must prove the offence. If there is a conviction, the court passes sentence.

The section 60A hearing: the last chance before an indictment

A suspect who is about to be indicted for a felony (an offence punishable by more than 3 years’ imprisonment) has a right to a hearing under section 60A of the Criminal Procedure Law. The suspect may put forward arguments and try to persuade the State Attorney’s Office or the police prosecution not to indict, or to narrow the indictment, so that a decision of this weight is not taken before the suspect has had a fair opportunity to be heard.

The process starts with letters. When the investigation ends and the police believe there is a sufficient evidential basis, the material is passed to the police prosecution or the State Attorney’s Office and the suspect receives a first notification letter saying so. No decision has yet been made, and a lawyer contacted at this stage can open a dialogue with the prosecution that may stop the indictment early. If the prosecution then decides there is enough evidence and a public interest in prosecution, a second letter follows, sometimes called a “letter of suspicions”. It states that an indictment is being considered, and in some cases a draft indictment is attached. From that moment the suspect has 30 days to put forward arguments. If you have received a notification letter, do not wait for the next one.

After the hearing

Having examined the defence arguments and the evidence, the prosecution may close the file, return it to the police for further investigation, amend or reduce the suspected offences where the evidence is narrower than first claimed, offer an improved conditional arrangement in some cases, or file an indictment. Because the file can be sent back for investigation after the suspect has been heard, arguments that could do harm should not be raised. Whatever the decision, it has to be acted on at once.

How a criminal defence lawyer helps at a section 60A hearing

A criminal defence lawyer files a reasoned submission, including alternatives to prosecution that suit the case, and may set out personal circumstances, such as harm to employment, a rehabilitation process or the passage of time, that justify not indicting or filing a lighter indictment.

I founded the firm in 1998 and have practised criminal law, extradition and international crime since then, and I serve as Chairman of the Extradition and International Crime Committee of the Israel Bar Association. If you have been called to a hearing, contact us. We can be reached 24/7 on +972-3-6969080.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a police record and a criminal record?

A police record is internal information about investigations, files awaiting a decision on prosecution and files that were closed. A criminal record is created only after a conviction in court. A criminal record has its own statutory rules on expiry and erasure, while a police record can be erased or cancelled in suitable circumstances.

Which ground for closing a file leaves no police record?

Only closure for lack of guilt. It is a finding that the suspect did not commit the offence, and so the information is erased from the police record.

My file was closed for insufficient evidence or lack of public interest. Can the ground be changed to lack of guilt?

Yes. A reasoned application to change the ground of closure is filed, preferably through an experienced criminal lawyer. If it is refused, an appeal can be filed within 60 days. The outcome depends on the evidence, the failings identified and other relevant considerations.

What is the difference between the first and the second notification letter?

The first letter tells the suspect that the investigation material has been passed from the police to the prosecution for review. The second letter, the “letter of suspicions”, says that the prosecution is considering an indictment, and a draft is sometimes attached. From receipt of the second letter there are 30 days to submit arguments under the right to a hearing.

Can the 30 days be extended?

In suitable cases, yes, by filing a reasoned request for an extension. It is better not to wait until the last moment.

Does a conditional arrangement erase the police record?

No. A conditional arrangement replaces an indictment with agreed conditions and a penalty, such as a fine, compensation or community service. It does not erase the police record, but it avoids a criminal trial and a conviction, saves time and strain, and gives certainty about the outcome. Take advice as soon as such an arrangement is offered.

This page provides general information and is not a substitute for legal advice based on the facts of a particular case. A Hebrew version of this page is available at סגירת תיק פלילי ושימוע לפי סעיף 60א: מחיקת רישום משטרתי ושינוי עילת סגירה.