When another state seeks your surrender

Extradition Lawyer in Israel: Extradition Law and Proceedings

Arrested abroad, or in Israel and wanted by another state, the first stage of the case shapes everything that follows.

What the Extradition Law, 5714-1954 provides, when extradition from Israel is barred, and how a request moves from the court to the Minister of Justice.

Perhaps you have been arrested abroad at the request of another country. Perhaps you are in Israel and have learned that the authorities of another state want you handed over to them. In either situation, advice from a lawyer who works in extradition makes a difference from the very first stage, because extradition files are often complex and the early decisions shape the rest of the case.

Why extradition law exists

Cooperation between the world’s 193 states grows every year, in trade, security and technology, and alongside it in policing and the law. Its purpose in the legal field is to ensure that a person who commits an offence outside their own country does not escape punishment. That principle underlies extradition law, which rests on many international treaties, among them treaties to which Israel is a party.

What extradition law covers

Extradition law deals with the legal process in which a state is asked to hand over a person who is in its territory to another state, either to stand trial or to serve a sentence already imposed. The process combines criminal law, international law and domestic law, and it examines a series of substantive and procedural conditions: the nature of the offence and its seriousness, the evidence, the rights of the person sought, and whether the request complies with the relevant law and treaties.

What an extradition agreement does

An extradition agreement is a legal agreement between states that sets the rules and conditions under which a person may be extradited from one to the other. Among other things, it defines which offences are extradition offences, which exceptions apply, what a valid request must contain, and how the needs of law enforcement are balanced against the human rights of the person sought. An agreement does not in itself guarantee that extradition will take place. Each request is examined on its own merits, under the domestic law of the requested state, the rulings of its courts and the circumstances of the particular case.

The Extradition Law, 5714-1954: what it provides

Extradition from Israel is governed by the Extradition Law, 5714-1954. People whose extradition is sought, and their families, usually ask the same questions, and the answers are found in a handful of its sections:

  • What an extradition offence is: any offence which, had it been committed in Israel, would carry a penalty of one year’s imprisonment or more (section 2). A person declared extraditable for one such offence may also be extradited for lesser offences in the same case.
  • The basic condition: an extradition agreement between Israel and the requesting state (section 2A). The agreement may be a bilateral treaty, a multilateral convention or a special agreement made for a particular case. Israel acts on the basis of reciprocity, unless the Minister of Justice decides otherwise.
  • When extradition is barred: section 2B lists the exceptions. They include an offence of a political character, a suspicion that the request was made out of discrimination on grounds of race or religion, a military offence, a person who has already stood trial in Israel for the same act, an offence or penalty that has lapsed under Israeli law, a pardon in the requesting state, and harm to public policy or to a vital interest of the State.
  • Israeli citizens and residents: under section 1A, a person who is an Israeli citizen and resident is extradited only to stand trial, and only if the requesting state has undertaken in advance to return him to Israel to serve any prison sentence that is imposed.
  • Where the case is heard: in the Jerusalem District Court, on a petition by the Attorney General (section 3). The court declares a person extraditable if it is shown that there is evidence which would be sufficient to put him on trial in Israel, and that the other conditions are met (section 9).
  • Appeal and the final decision: the court’s decision may be appealed to the Supreme Court within 30 days (section 13). Even once the declaration is final, the decision to carry out the extradition rests with the Minister of Justice (section 18).

In practice, most of the work in an extradition file revolves around these questions: whether there is sufficient evidence, whether one of the bars applies, and what is happening at the same time in the requesting state. Where the case began with an international arrest notice, our separate page on INTERPOL and Red Notices deals with that side of it.

The main stages of extradition proceedings

The request and its review

The proceedings open when the requesting state submits a formal extradition request, setting out the offences attributed to the person sought, the evidence available and the agreements or law that apply between the two states. The authorities of the requested state then check whether it meets the formal and substantive conditions of the law and the international conventions. In Israel, the competent legal authorities review the request before it is brought before a court.

The court hearing and decision

The court examines the conditions for extradition on their merits, including the nature and seriousness of the offence, whether there is prima facie evidence, whether the rights of the person sought are protected, and whether a legal exception prevents extradition. After hearing both sides, it decides whether the conditions are met. The decision may approve extradition in full, reject the request or impose restrictive conditions.

Final approval and surrender

In some cases the executive must also approve after the court has ruled, and in Israel that decision belongs to the Minister of Justice. Only once every approval has been given does the surrender take place.

The role of an extradition lawyer

In extradition matters, the lawyer’s role goes well beyond formal representation before surrender becomes a fact, because of what is at stake for the person sought. Beyond ongoing advice, an extradition lawyer carries out tasks that directly affect whether the proceedings go ahead and how they end:

  • Testing the legality of the request: whether it was made in accordance with the law, the relevant agreements and the binding legal standards.
  • Protecting the rights of the person sought: including the right not to be extradited to a state that does not conduct a fair trial or that violates fundamental rights.
  • Examining the evidence: whether there is prima facie evidence, and arguing where it is missing or too weak to justify a declaration of extraditability.
  • Double criminality: checking whether the alleged conduct is also an offence under Israeli law, and raising the argument where it is not.
  • Building the legal case: raising every substantive and procedural argument that could stop the proceedings or lead to the request being rejected.

How we act at each stage

The strategy is adjusted to each stage and its possible consequences:

  • Early advice: assessing the risks as soon as there is a concern about arrest or an extradition request.
  • Analysing the request: reviewing the request, the evidence and the attached documents, and building a line of defence for the specific case.
  • In court: representing the person sought at the hearings and making sure his rights are fully respected.
  • After each decision: reviewing interim decisions and rulings and taking the steps the circumstances require.
  • Through to the final decision: acting at the later stages too, including the related approvals, to limit the harm to the person’s liberty and rights.

Why an Israeli lawyer should stay involved

When an Israeli is sought by another state, it matters that an Israeli lawyer deals with the matter in front of the authorities seeking the extradition, and makes sure the person has proper legal representation after surrender. Criminal proceedings in Israel already bring helplessness, tension and uncertainty, and in extradition proceedings those feelings are sharper still.

The person surrendered often does not speak the language of the state that receives him. Difficulty communicating with the foreign lawyer who represents him, unfamiliarity with the way trials are conducted there and the constant fear of detention in a foreign prison weigh on him throughout. In the foreign court, representation is by a locally admitted lawyer. Our firm runs the strategy, keeps in contact with the family and handles the Israeli side, and for that reason we stay as closely involved as possible in the whole extradition process.

While an extradition request is pending, the court often releases the person sought on conditions, which include a ban on leaving the country. Whether such a ban is in force, and how to apply for permission to travel, are among the first things we check.

Many extradition files are tied to a particular country. Our country pages cover cases connected with the United States, Germany, the United Kingdom, France, Greece, Italy, Cyprus, Turkey, Georgia, Portugal, Thailand, Hungary, Ukraine, India and Dubai and the UAE.

Our extradition practice

Our firm advises and represents people whose extradition is sought, from the first hearing on the request through to the handling of the surrender itself if the request is granted. Sharon Nahari has practised criminal law, extradition and international crime since 1998. He is Chairman of the Extradition and International Crime Committee of the Israel Bar Association and one of Israel’s senior criminal lawyers. Our aim is to keep the legal harm to the person sought as small as possible. We can be reached 24/7 on +972-3-6969080.

Frequently asked questions

What is an extradition offence under Israeli law?

Under section 2 of the Extradition Law, any offence which, had it been committed in Israel, would carry a penalty of one year’s imprisonment or more.

Does Israel extradite its own citizens?

Yes, on conditions. A person who is an Israeli citizen and resident is extradited only to stand trial, and only if the requesting state has undertaken in advance to return him to serve any prison sentence in Israel (section 1A).

Where is an extradition request heard?

In the Jerusalem District Court. The decision may be appealed to the Supreme Court within 30 days, and the decision to carry out the extradition rests with the Minister of Justice.

Can Israel extradite without an extradition treaty?

The law requires an agreement, but the agreement can be a special agreement made for a particular case, and Israel acts on the basis of reciprocity. The absence of a general treaty therefore does not rule out extradition.

When is extradition barred?

Among other cases, where the offence is of a political character, where there is a suspicion of discrimination on grounds of race or religion, where the person has already stood trial in Israel for the same act, where the offence has lapsed under Israeli law, or where extradition would harm public policy (section 2B).

Official legal sources

This page provides general information and is not a substitute for legal advice based on the facts of a particular case. A Hebrew version of this page is available at דיני הסגרה.